In the midst of rising nationalism and increasingly aggressive immigration enforcement, one legal question deserves renewed attention: Do non-citizens have constitutional rights in the United States? The short answer is yes—but the story is more complex, and the stakes are higher than they appear.

The United States Constitution doesn’t just protect “citizens.” It uses broader language—like “persons” and “people.” That distinction is neither accidental nor trivial. From the very beginning, the American legal tradition has extended core protections to anyone under U.S. jurisdiction, regardless of citizenship status. This includes one of the oldest and most vital legal protections in Western law: habeas corpus, the right to challenge unlawful detention.

The principle is simple but profound: no government should have the unchecked power to hold people without cause. Habeas corpus is the brake on arbitrary imprisonment. And while it’s often associated with dramatic wartime cases, it also quietly anchors fairness in civil and immigration law every day.

Consider Boumediene v. Bush (2008), where the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that even foreign nationals detained at Guantanamo Bay—outside formal U.S. territory—had a constitutional right to seek habeas corpus relief. The Court reasoned that when the U.S. exercises total control over a location and a person, constitutional protections follow. It was a powerful rebuke to the idea that the government can sidestep the Constitution simply by moving its actions offshore.

That ruling followed Rasul v. Bush (2004), which similarly affirmed that federal courts have jurisdiction to hear habeas petitions from non-citizens in U.S. custody. And going even further back, in Yick Wo v. Hopkins (1886), the Court made clear that constitutional guarantees—including due process and equal protection—apply to all persons, not just citizens.

This matters not only in theoretical or moral terms but in practical, daily realities. Immigration detention, for example, is one of the largest civil detention systems in the world. Thousands of people—including asylum seekers, visa overstayers, and even permanent residents—are held without criminal charges, sometimes for months or years. The only reason many avoid indefinite detention is because courts still honor habeas corpus petitions, allowing them to challenge their confinement.

Despite this legal foundation, the public conversation often paints non-citizens as “outsiders” without rights. But the Constitution isn’t a permission slip handed out with a passport. It’s a framework designed to limit government power and uphold individual dignity—even when that’s inconvenient.

Some will argue that granting constitutional protections to non-citizens creates legal complexity or undermines national security. But complexity isn’t an excuse for injustice. And security without accountability is simply tyranny under a different name.

As immigration debates intensify, the line between citizenship and personhood should not be blurred. Constitutional rights are not just for the privileged few. They are, by design, the floor beneath our collective freedom. If we erode those rights for some, we eventually erode them for all.